Trial of Severus Snape /Harry IS Snape./A cold equation (LONG)

[nrenka]

No: HPFGUIDX 141418

--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "colebiancardi" <muellem at b...> 
wrote:

<snippage in which Pippin stated an argument that Harry has seen and 
heard complete dialogues via Legilimency>

> end of Pippin's great post.  Thanks for finding that cannon!  So, it
> has worked before, it is cannon and it works artistically, as no one
> had problems with those scenes (at least I cannot find any issues 
> with them on this board).

All hands to starboard, fire those cannons!

The problem with this is, of course, that Harry has an explicitly 
exceptional connection with Voldemort.  All of these situations may 
involve Legilimency, but there's this complicating factor, and 
no 'control group' to set these things against.  Ergo, it is 
impossible to say that any other character could be privy to the 
things in the same manner as Harry has.

-Nora leans towards the mysterious connection with Voldemort, which 
Dumbledore extolls as one of Harry's unique weapons, as being the 
controlling factor in all of Pippin's 'canonical' assertions, not 
Legilimency per se