Trial of Severus Snape /Harry IS Snape./A cold equation (LONG)

[ibchawz]

No: HPFGUIDX 141459


> Alla wrote:
<snip>
>because  the future of WW hangs on whether Harry will be 
> able to retrieve all FOUR horcruxes and may I say again - 
Dumbledore 
> himself only managed TWO so far. 

<Super-mega snip of multiple screens of post>

ibchawz responds:

Which TWO horcruxes did Dumbledore retrieve / destroy?  I only know 
of ONE that Dumbledore has retrieved / destroyed - The ring horcrux.  
Harry actually destroyed the diary horcrux and he did this before he 
even knew about Horcruxes.

I snipped the remainder of the post since I am, as Lupinlore put it, 
in the "great middle".  While I can see and understand valid points 
brought up by each side of the debate, I can also poke holes in each 
theory such that none of them hold water.

ibchawz - Going back into lurk mode regarding the ESE/OFH/ESG/DDM 
Snape debate.