Snape's allegiance (Was: A couple of little theories!)

[Phyllis D. (P. D.) Barnes]

No: HPFGUIDX 162393


Carol:
<SNIP of the whole post pretty much>
>> At any rate, those are some of the reasons that I believe Snape is
> Dumbledore's man through and through, regardless of the curves that
> HBP throws at us. I could cite other evidence from other books, but
> you get the picture.
<SNIP>

I agree the Foe-Glass is strong proof that Snape is DDM; but I still
believe the incontrovertable proof is Dumbledore himself.  Dumbledore
trusted Snape.  I do not believe that a wizard of Dumbledore's power
and wisdome could have been fooled if Snape wasn't genuine.  I
believe that Book 7 will prove that Dumbledore's trust was justified.

But outside of being on the right-side in the fight against Voldy;
Snape is not a good guy.  He's cruel to the students that are not in
his house.

Phyllis.