CHAPDISC: HBP8, Snape Victorious -- Dumbledore's hand

[kmalone1127]

No: HPFGUIDX 146598


> Sherry:
> > 12.  Throughout the book, Harry asks about Dumbledore's hand, 
> > and he is repeatedly told that he'll learn what happened later. 
> > He never does.  Will the exact details of what happened to the 
> > hand be important later, either in what Harry has to do or in 
> > understanding what happened on the tower?

kmalone1127 <kmalone1127 at y...> wrote:
> #12. This is interesting. I don't think DD told him because it 
> meant he was dying. There is a very good theory about this at
> HogwartsProfessor.com. It is too long to summarize here but it is
> worth reading. I think he might have told Harry if circumstances 
> had been different at the end of the book.


Just an addendum.  The theory I mentioned is titled "Why Half-Blood
Prince is the Best Harry Potter Novel".  Again, the site is
http://www.hogwartsprofessor.com/home.php .

kmalone1127