[HPforGrownups] Re: The Scar - 'All or Nothing' Clarification

[Sean-Michael]

No: HPFGUIDX 160274

 bboyminn: (responding in general)wrote:

 I will once again bring everyone's notice to the paragraph
 above that I highlighted with stars ('*'). I don't
 personally believe that Harry will lose his powers. What I
 am objecting to and responding to is the 'all or nothing'
 approach that people who /do/ believe this are taking.

<clip>

 Back to the main point, what I object to is the idea that
 /IF/ Harry loses his powers, that he will be completely
 cut off from the magical world. I don't think so. He
 will still have his friends, he will still have access to
 their world. Admittedly it will be painful for Harry to
 have to do this, to have been so magically important and
 to now be dependant on others for magic. But being
 dependant on others for magic doesn't mean Harry will
 suddenly be helpless, pointless, or worthless. <clip'd the rest>

Sean-Michael's quick point:
I tend to agree with bboyminn on his above points. I also think that the fact that Harry gave the Weasley twins the money to start up their "joke shop" which seems to me a bit more than your average shop didn't they have cures for some things in there as well....sort of a joke shop/magical apothecary? Anyway... I believe the weasly twins would provide Harry with various magical items as would other people in his life even if he were left with no magic...which I doubt.

I also believe the gold his parents left him would provide for many things in the magical world he would need. Can't forget the value of a bit of gold even in the magical world. Plus he has at least one house elf who is completely capable of protecting him magically as shown when Dobby stopped Malfoy Sr from using the unforgivable death curse...Avada cadavre is it?

Just some thoughts ;)






Sean-Michael
http://smbryceart.etsy.com
http://smbryceart.pbwiki.com
http://smbryceart.livejournal.com
http://www.artbyus.com/auctions.php?a=6&b=4533