witches of the world (was: Lavender vs Hermione)

[Tesha]

No: HPFGUIDX 160417

 
> Magpie:
> But...isn't that what you're saying, that it was a fine thing?  You 
> seemed to be disagreeing she'd even done the things I'd said she'd 
> done. 

Tesha:
She read a book that was in the "Banned Area" She took some material
from a teacher's private stock. She made and made available a spiked
treat. She used her skills and knowlege to help her friend find out
some information that might have helped save others. There was no
violence, there was no physical harm (except to herself) - and she is
just a child - I think that's pretty remarkable. 


I fail to see how you come to these conclusion... unless you simply
despise her???

> Magpie:
> She is a bit better than the murderous sociopath advocating genocide. 
 
>Betsy Hp:
>Marietta was wrong. Hermione was horrifying.

(This is rather of like hearing my husband's ex list off all the
horrible things he's ever done in his life to prove he's worthy of her
distain - when in fact he's the sweetest man I've ever met - we're
going to just have to agree to disagree)