my DH reactions minus Snape
prep0strus
prep0strus at yahoo.com
Wed Jul 25 02:56:40 UTC 2007
No: HPFGUIDX 172517
--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "M.Clifford" <Aisbelmon at ...> wrote:
> It seems to me that the second time, in the Great Hall, then, Harry
> was the undisputed Master of Death. That was the moment when he took
> possession of the last Hallow and mastered it in his magical control,
> the only thing he hadn't done yet, and so in that moment, he could not
> die. Voldemort's immortality was gone as of Nagini's death so he could
> die, and via the shared blood it is possible he could have taken Harry
> with him, it was at that moment, I believe, that Harry had achieved
> the legendary immortality bestowed by the Hallows and thus couldn't
die.
>
This is really interesting. But it also assumes that possession
doesn't require being in the presence or physical control of a Hallow.
That being the case... wouldn't Harry still be the master of all
three objects for as long as no one finds the stone in the woods or
bests harry in a duel? Making him, in effect, immortal?
The besting in a duel, I'm sorry to say, still baffles me, though I've
been following the threads for thoughts. What truly transfers
ownership of the elder wand, and why was Harry able to take mastery
from Draco, but Voldy didn't get it from Harry when he blasted him?
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive