What Harry "knows", Was Why we'll get no further revelations Snape was Evil

[dumbledore11214]

No: HPFGUIDX 169848

> > Dana:
> > So now  we only have to wait for Snape to make an attempt on 
Lupin's
> > life and 
> > Snape has eliminated every single person he thought to have 
> > responsibility in that night's events.
> 
> colebiancardi:
> 
> WOW!  Snape is not responsible for the death of Sirius.  Snape has
> never tried to kill Lupin, and he had plenty of opportunities in PoA
> with the monthly potion.  Snape delivered 1/2 of the prophecy to LV,
> but by turning to DD, ensured his place, IMHO, that he was working
> against LV and tried to prevent the deaths of the Potters.
>

Alla:

The list member whose writings I simply love ( among many others) and 
agree with once said that maybe it will all turn out to be about 
Snape 
grudge indeed. Now, I cannot exclude the possibility obviously and do 
not really want to.

But Snape meticulously waiting to strike out at every single 
Marauder.. 
Bleh. I hope not. I hope he is not **that** pathetic. I mean, I think 
Jen's theory about him being responsible in some way for Sirius death 
makes sense, but not Snape making his life purpose to kill James, 
Sirius and Lupin.

Although, Snape seems to me to make his life purpose to make Harry's 
life miserable sounds to me to be **that** pathetic, but still.

But yes, one can wonder indeed. I totally hold Snape responsible for 
death of James and Lily. In part of course, Voldemort bears more 
blame.

Snape **himself** took credit for Sirius' death, whether one believes 
him or not.

All we left is Lupin indeed.


Hmmmm, Dana, I do not want you to be right - not because I have any 
sympathy for Snape, but because I find him much more fascinating and 
multilayered evil if he has some dignity and won't do something that 
pathetic, but I won't exclude the possibility <g>

JMO of course and speculative one at that,

Alla.