LV's bigger plan (was:Fawkes possible absence)/ some War and peace

hickengruendler hickengruendler at yahoo.de
Sat Mar 24 22:49:34 UTC 2007


No: HPFGUIDX 166433

  
> Alla:
> 
> Right, I totally see where Jen is coming from here. I mean, here we 
> come again to the what is truth and what is lie in Spinner End, I 
> guess.
> 
> Truthfully, I would be delighted if everything that was said in 
> Spinner End was true, but since Snape's tale gets questioned so 
> exstensively, since when Bella and Narcissa are the most reliable 
> witnesses? Not IMO.
> 
> I mean, Magpie is right that everything that was said fits what 
> happened in HBP, BUT IMO if something will be twisted ( and I am 
not 
> saying it would be), JKR can easily do it by showing Black sisters 
> lies.
>  

Hickengruendler:

Except that the chapter doesn't start with Snape. It begins with 
Narcissa and Bellatrix arguing, if Narcissa should go to Snape. And 
during this chapter Bellatrix says "This is a betrayal of the dark 
Lord's...". She is interrupted by Narcissa then, but I assume she 
wanted to say plans. That means if there is some secret pla with 
Voldemort involved, Bella does not know about it, which makes it 
highly unlikely. 





More information about the HPforGrownups archive