Lupin and Tonks WAS: I am so happy. There is a gay - Triumph & Tragedy

[dumbledore11214]

No: HPFGUIDX 178230


"Catlady (Rita Prince Winston)" <catlady at ...> wrote:

> Supposed by whom? The author didn't intend it to be 
disturbing<snipped> 
> I, however, *am* disturbed by it, because what is on the page 
looks to
> me like Lupin never loved Tonks except as a friend, never wanted to
> marry her or live with her, never wanted to have a child, and got
> dragged into all those things against his (weak) will. <SNIP>

Alla:

I honestly wanted to give Lupin/ Tonks a chance after HBP. I really 
did. The fact that I grew to like my Sirius/ Lupin ( not as much as 
Sirius/ Snape mind you) did not mean that I did not want Lupin to be 
happy.

I kept telling myself, oh no, no he just deludes himself and he is 
just too afraid to give himself and Tonks a chance, insecure, etc.

Here comes DH. Lupin basically **runnig away** from Tonks, till 
Harry yells at him, IMO. And Tonks as always runs after him.

I saw no great love there, when Lupin would rather be with Trio than 
with his pregnant wife.


OOOOOOOOO. Duh Alla. Another unrequited love in the series? Tonks of 
Lupin maybe?

Maybe?

JMO,

Alla