James and Sirius as Bullies/ some Snape

[Jayne]

No: HPFGUIDX 181235

Alla wrote

> <SNIP>
> 

> Again, by this I do not mean that his character arc was unresolved, 
> of course it was – he was loyal to Dumbledore and loved Lily, BUT 
> case in point – did he hate Harry till the end or did he not?
> 
> Do we know this part? I thought it was super clear, even if one 
does 
> not read the interviews. I thought when Snape screams to 
> Dumbledore " him?", that is a clear indication that Snape hates 
> Harry and hated him till he died, but I am aware of the 
> interpretation that Snape here evades the question and that shows 
> that he does not hate Harry no more. Do I agree with this 
> interpretation? Of course not but I certainly accept it as valid 
> possibility.

I think that as he conjured up his patronus of his doe like Lily's at 
that time, it shows to me that he did not hate Harry. In fact i think 
he had grown to respect him ,maybe than like him ,although he would 
never admit it.
Just my opinion which is often wrong

Jayne