Which scene we hated more or loved WAS: Re: Why not Actually Re-Write?

[kat7555]

No: HPFGUIDX 180326

> va32h:

> I liked and disliked that scene. Harry as a willing sacrifice?
> Fine, good, touching etc. His parents rooting him on? Turned
> my stomach. <SNIP>

> I think James, Sirius and Lily could have a tad less enthusiasm
> for sending Harry to his death, is all I'm saying.

Kathy:
I think James and Lily already knew Harry would survive. I
believe when Dumbledore died James and Lily demanded to know
what would happen to their son. Dumbledore told them about
Harry being a Horcrux and that he would have to be killed in
order to repair his soul. They don't say anything about Harry
reuniting with them in the afterlife because they know Harry
will go on to adulthood. Kathy Kulesza