GoF CH 27-29 Post DH look/ Snape and Harry redux

[dumbledore11214]

No: HPFGUIDX 182211

Pippin:
<SNIP>
 As you admit above, JKR made Voldemort so deadly that with one
exception to prove the rule, everyone who belonged to the fighting
wing of the original Order died. Lily and James might have survived if
Voldemort's forces were less deadly, of course. But they weren't.

Alla:

I did admit that? I thought I stressed specifically that quite a few of 
order members survived the first war at least. I "thank" Snape for Lily 
and James NOT surviving that.

And again, who says that Lily and James would not have been just as 
lucky as Hagrid? Is the fact that they defied Voldemort three times 
matters only as much as them fighting Voldemort? Does it not matter 
that they **succesfully** defied Voldemort to increase their survival 
chances?

And  there are Molly and Arthur of course.





Pippin:
<SNIP>
> Harry is Voldemort's number one target, but that doesn't stop him from
> killing loads of other people, especially  Order members. 

Alla:

Sure. Harry is his **number one** target, makes whole lot of difference 
to me.

Pippin:
 Tell me, if
> you were an Order member, and you knew you *hadn't* been targeted by a
> prophecy saying you might destroy Voldemort, would you feel safe? 


Alla:

Safe? Of course not,but you bet that without prophecy over my head and 
my child's head I would have felt safer, MUCH safer.

JMO<

Alla