Did Harry Notice?

casa_corse casa_corse at yahoo.com
Mon May 12 18:33:20 UTC 2008


No: HPFGUIDX 182872

> Mike:
> After the things Voldemort had told Harry about his dad in PS/SS
> and in the graveyard of GoF, we and Harry were under the impression
> that James had put up a *good* fight, or at least had represented
> himself well. I don't see how standing in front of Voldemort,
> wandless, waiting to be AKed can be construed, as Voldemort himself
> said in PS: "Yes, boy, your parents were brave... I killed your
> father first,and he put up a courageous fight..." <SS p.294, US>



I'm very new to this group but I just read this post and wanted to
point out that Voldemort would have said he put up a courageous fight
no matter what. He always wanted to give the impression that he was
always the best. Remember he did it again in the Deathly Hallows, when
he made his way back to the castle with what he thought was Harry's
dead body. He lied there too, to make himself look more powerfull. He
said that Harry ran away in fear rather than try and fight. Well those
are my thoughts on the post,

alice





More information about the HPforGrownups archive