Disarming spell/ Character's choices

[dumbledore11214]

No: HPFGUIDX 185485

> > Alla:
> > So basically you are saying that Harry said it for self indulgence, 
> > right? As I said, I cannot disprove it, but I cannot buy it, I do
> not think. 
> 
> Kemper now:
<SNIP>
> Do you think Harry believed that Voldemort would repent?  I don't
> think he did. 

Alla:

Honestly, I have no idea. However, I cannot completely exclude the 
possibility, especially after seeing that Harry up there did attempt at 
least to help the creature under the table.

I would not be surprised that especially after being cleansed up there, 
he felt a need to help Voldemort. But I cannot say one way or another.

Kemper:
 But if I were Harry, I would also let Voldemort know
> that he could repent.  If Harry didn't give Voldemort that little soul
> saving information, he would be more active in killing Voldemort. 
> <--- I know that's not a cogent thought, but I'm too tired to flesh it
> out; my apologies... :)

Alla:

Oh no problem, I feel like I am not making much sense in this thread 
myself lol, but indeed would you mind clarifying?

If you indeed did not believe at all, not one hundred part of one 
percent that Voldemort would repent, why would you say it?

I know that if I would not believed it, I would not have said it, to me 
it will be a waste of words and I would really have other concerns in 
the final battle with a very dangerous villain than to offer him a 
possibility to save his soul, which I know he would not take?