Hermione and her parents Redux WAS: Re: Wizarding Top Ten

[dumbledore11214]

No: HPFGUIDX 188203





> Kemper now:
> No.  I don't see it as less.  The possibility of her death remains
> constant with our without my memories.<SNIP>
> 
Kemper now:
I don't understand the circumstance in which I face the immediacy of
her death or my memories. That doesn't seem what's going on in the
text.<SNIP>


Alla:

I think in these two sentences is the crust of our disagreement. You do not seem to think that you as Hermione's imaginary parent can be used as a sitting duck by Voldemort to lure Hermione and her friends out of hiding and into Voldemort's hands, right? To me it is what would have happened had Hermione not done what she did. I of course cannot argue that it is what would have necessarily happened, but to me it is pretty clear that you without memories are significantly less likely to give to Voldemort the information about Harry that Hermione told her parents and which could have helped Voldie find the clue how to set up a trap.

I guess we are at stalemate and I have to quit this discussion at least for now, because to me this is a pretty obvious consequence and obviously you are on the opposite end, I just do not see any common points in our views on this one.

Till next time Kemper :-)

Alla