FILK: Dumbledore's Dead + the UV

quigonginger quigonginger at quigonginger.yahoo.invalid
Sat Aug 6 03:14:20 UTC 2005


Yay!  Pippin did that tune quite a while ago, and it was brilliant.  
Here's the link:

http://home.att.net/~coriolan/students/wood.htm#Oliver-Wood

Have you sent your version to CMC?  He's updating, you know.  Or if 
you posted on the main list, he'll get it there.

I like the "bird has flown" comparison to the phoenix flying away.  
Good fit.  

As long as I'm here, another thought entered my mind today.

Snape was supposed to kill DD if Draco failed, and if he (Snape) 
didn't, then he (Snape) would die.  Draco failed twice and Snape 
didn't do it, but he lived.  Does this mean that as long as Draco was 
still trying and intending on succeeding that the Vow didn't kick 
in?  But it only kicked in if Draco failed and wasn't going to try 
again (or couldn't try again)?  In which case, DD must have been 
dying or Snape could have just let Draco try again and again and 
Snape would have been ok.

Unless Snape Legilimanced Draco and saw that he (Draco) had truely 
had a change of heart, in which case, this could be interesting.

Thoughts?  
Ginger, hoping Sean does a filk #3.







More information about the the_old_crowd archive